Skip to main content

Review Retrospective: Gears of War

Above is an image of Dan Hsu/1UP's review of Gears of War way back from 2006. Reading it now, in retrospect, you get to realize how unreliable video game reviews are these days.

Despite all the negative comments in that review (even going so far as to calling Gears' multiplayer as 'broken') the game is still one of the most popular games on the Xbox 360. It's still hanging on in Major Nelson's Top 10 games on Xbox Live:

http://majornelson.com/archive/2008/07/02/live-activity-for-week-of-june-23rd.aspx

"Xbox 360 Top Live Titles (based on UU’s)
1 Call of Duty 4
2 Halo 3
3 GTA IV
4 Battlefield: Bad Company Demo
5 Guitar Hero III
6 Gears of War
7 Rock Band
8 Battlefield: Bad Company
9 Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six® Vegas 2
10 FIFA 08 "


Not bad for a game with "broken multiplayer" and supposedly imprecise gameplay mechanics with the melee combat....And later on it turns out that the 'imprecise, hard to control' chainsaw is everyone's favorite aspect of the game, becoming the most memorable aspect of Gears' gameplay.

This is one of those reviews that, when you look back years after it was written, clearly damages the credibility of the one that wrote it. Does this writer really know games, and what games appeal to the gamers of today? Does he know what differentiates a good game from a terrible one? It's also one of those examples where newer game franchises never seem to get a fair shake from the gaming press, who seem to hand out 10's freely to established names and look over their flaws, while calling out other, newer game brands for one or two moments of framerate stutter; usually deducting a whole point (or more) for a small infraction.

Anyway, right now Dan Hsu no longer writes for 1UP and works now for Microsoft Game Studios(Ironically, he's on the same team working on Gears of War 2), but this clever piece of writing serves as a reminder for gamers that game reviews are just another opinion from just another gamer---they aren't the end-all-be-all-ultimate-final-judgment on the quality of a particular game title. In fact it's entirely possible that a great game can get a horrible rating and be missed out on by so many gamers--that's a sad reality in today's gaming industry, that the hard work of some developers can be disregarded by many gamers with just a paragraph or two of ill-informed diatribe. The Gears of War series, in a way, got lucky that reviews like that one weren't enough to stop it from being a multi-million dollar hit. I can't imagine what kind of effect reviews like that could have to other similar, smaller budgeted (and less marketed) games. I'm not saying that most games that get low ratings are probably good---I'm sure there are lots of bad titles out there that get the score that they deserve. It's just that I totally loathe the practice of having higher standards for newer game franchises and handing out free passes for much older, established game franchises (i.e. game sequels) with huge fanbases. I'm guessing that most sites are afraid of getting hate mail or losing site visitors if they tell it like it is for a game that has a well established legacy, or for a series that adheres to a time-honored tradition (even if said tradition is already showing its age in the face of newer gameplay mechanics).

I think it's best for gamers to set aside reviews as just another opinion in the sea of opinions that are available right now. With the Internet you can find even more feedback on the games that get released, and surely it's possible to find feedbacks which coincide with one's own taste in games. Furthermore, it's becoming easier to simply try a game before deciding whether or not to buy it. Game demos are readily available, and in some cases you can simply just rent a game and decide for yourself if its worth it. Overall, the value of 'game reviews' as a measure of game quality has clearly diminished. Often when a new game gets released I don't even go straight to the review; I prefer visiting an online forum and reading everyone's opinion on a game and making up my mind about it by then, then I just compliment that by actually trying the game if a demo is available. I've also noticed that when I recommend a game, I only rate it three ways, and I don't really like to give it a numerical score: A game can be worth buying, worth borrowing/renting, or it's totally not worth buying at all. Then I usually just say what I like about it, in general/as a whole. I don't really nitpick little details like the occasional framerate problem unless it makes a game completely unplayable. That's my current standard when it comes to talking about what I think about a particular game.

In today's connected world, it's far easier to make up your own mind about something because all the means to do so are available to you (thanks to technology). I'm just surprised that despite this, people still cling to having some authority tell them what's good and what's terrible. Maybe it's just human nature to have someone else approve or disapprove of your own tastes.

Don't let other people stop you from having fun on your own terms.

Popular posts from this blog

Gamers based in the Philippines: How to get in Xbox Live

NOTE: This article has recently been updated (as of August 12, 2006). Singapore no longer lets you input '00000' as your zip code. Please see below for alternate zip codes.

So you're a Filipino living in the Philippines with a brand-spanking new Xbox 360. You've heard about all the wonderful stories on Xbox Live. You happen to have a pretty good broadband connection. One day, you try out the Xbox Live sign-up options on your 360, and you find out to your dismay that your country is NOT listed. What do you do?

Now, you can probably enjoy your 360 without live at all, but I have to tell you: YOU ARE MISSING OUT. As Peter Moore said in the recent MS Press Conference: "Having your 360 connected to Xbox Live is as vital as having your computer connected to the Internet".

He is so damned right.

I've been playing on Xbox Live for almost a year now (both on my original Xbox and the Xbox 360). Essentially I found out all of this with a little bit of research, a little…

Xbox One - System / Games general review

We picked up a [kinect-less] Xbox One a few weeks ago and have been putting it through its paces. Overall, right now I feel pretty good about this console. But I have to admit, the first experience of buying it is not very good. I'll go with the BAD news first. But do note that it isn't all bad news....

- The first time you bring it home, the console can't work without Internet. That's because it needs an absolutely-unoverrideable mandatory update. Basically, if you get this for your birthday and it's 7PM, expect to actually play games on it around a day or so later, depending on your internet speed.

- The first patch I got for it was around 800MB. This number might have changed by the time of this writing.

- All the launch games now have accumulated patches/updates over 16+ GB in size. Not just Dead Rising 3, which has been reported widely in the media. Even Forza 5.

- My internet at home is PLDT 3Mbps; managed to get all the updates pretty quickly....that's a…

E3 2015 Conferences from the Big Three - My thoughts

Microsoft:

- They get a lot of points from me for actually announcing games that will be out in 2015.
- The Backwards Compatibility update is a huge surprise that I absolutely did not expect. Having BC is difficult and expensive to do, but somehow MS managed to do it, which leads me to believe the solution they found is an inexpensive one if they've decided it's practical to do QA work for the Xbox 360s gigantic library of games and make them all work on the Xbox One. If it was too complicated or expensive they probably wouldn't have bothered. But since they did, I think we're going to see full BC some time soon for all games. It's only a matter of time.
- Halo 5 looked fantastic, but 343 has a lot of work to do to restore faith, after the horrific launch of the Halo Master Chief Collection. I think they can do it, and I'd imagine they're certainly motivated now. If they screw this one up....MS might reconsider forming a new team to handle the Halo franchis…